Why should you have fun without paying?
Why should F2P ruin the game for P2P.
Bots >> staking etc.
If the game should be P2P only, then half the people who play wouldn't be able to play. Do you think Jagex wants people to talk like this.
"I'm thinking about playing RuneScape."
"No, don't play that, you have to pay now."
"Wow, that's stupid. Why would they do that? That cuts the number of people who play in half."
"I know, that's the worst mistake they've ever made."
Why should you have to pay for horrible graphics? I can deal with it. It's free so why should I complain?
Don't count on this happening VxT. If this happens, people will switch to WOW. Basically the same game, better graphics, and I believe its the same fee. Which, you don't have to pay if you play in a private server.
BTW, I thought you quit VxT..??