-
10/10 BFM guest animation, thats very cool!
8/10 for the siggy
New thread for the Signature Game in order to remove all the old pages... takes up a lot of space on forums and many old links no longer valid.
Original Thread Start Credit goes to :
Tanger
Started on July 18, 2007
Only last few posts carried over... sorry to butt in lol
~BFM_Wic~
-
7/10
-
7/10
9/10
Second one awesome. Mine?
-
6/10
9/10
5/10
8/10
-
8/10 9/10
8/10 8/10
trying a new method, tell me if you like :)
(http://i598.photobucket.com/albums/tt69/Terra_55/Glow.jpg)
-
7/10 bit too rainbowish for me xD
-
Wow Terra
How did u do that
-
9/10 7/10
soccer sig? 8/10
-
10/10 Looks really cool and kinda abstract yet not,lol and it has the color purple :P
-
Ice age:8/10
Name:6/10 cos there isnt really much there
-
5/10 8/10
6/10 9/10
99/10 rofl
-
8/10, the colour works well...but is also it's downfall
-
8/10
-
9/10
-
9.5/10
rate this one please: (http://i326.photobucket.com/albums/k433/fanofbosox/aprilsig23.png)
-
7/10 its a little too blended, Rate my weegee sig :]
-
6/10
8/10 6/10
9/10
-
6/10, having lightning come out of the sig would have worked, but her swords chopped off =O! (i know the render was made like that)
side from that, not bad!
-
7/10... just seems a little too busy for my tastes
-
7/10 since it's monotonic and nothing is set up to catch one's eyes. Makes it flat.
-
8.5/10 nice colors :smly_a_wink:
-
8
10 (cos i made it ^^)
9
-
Wow that was a surprise seeing this thread saying I started it... O_O (Had to make a new sig just to point out my surprise...lol)
8, 6
9
-
9.3/10
-
5/10 >.> soz, its jsut a green and blue swirl imo
-
uhm, to 'revamp this, get it going again kind of? im double posting here.
8.5/10 (lol)
-
8
-
Love the colours Jay. Its like a Techno sorta siggy sooo 9/10
-
9.5/10 for the motorbike swirly one
8/10
-
4/10 over all
-
5/10...
haha... taste of ur own medicine, lol
-
Nothing to special about the top sig, so a solid 8.
But the bottom one is godly, so a 10.
-
8.5/10
-
6.4/10 7.5/10
-
8.7/10
-
6.5/10 - RETRO! I remember this. ;D
8/10 - Love the colours, the swirl is nice and symmetrical, and the text looks good.
-
113410234123894712398471230489712304981723401923740/10
-
7/10
8/10
... i have to rate hlao's cause it is just soooooooooo cute
10/10 :yesyes: ( it would be alot more if i could rate more, :LOL:)
-
8/10, love the mixing of cod4 + halo, classy looking.
9/10, gotta love simplistic animations done well :)
-
6/10 4/10
4.5/10
-
...Leo ur mean... try and give some good rates lol... but i did Leo's rate earlier... so someone can do both mine and LEO's
-
3/10 It just looks like 2 photos glued together
And leos gets a 4/10 its to Simple and the text could be more unique
-
I will go for a stingy 6 because Leo is a great gunner :P
-
7/10 8/10
10/10
-
7/10
8/10
-
7/10
Someone rate Projects again, Leo was mean ;D
(Rate mine aswell :XD: Can someone rate my avatar?)
-
9/10 for the avatar
7/10 average for the sig
-
7/10 - Kinda blurry, would be higher if it wasnt.
-
8/10
That's actually really cool though. :)
-
7ish/10 - Again, would be higher if it wasnt so blurry.
-
Alright took your advice and sharpened it up a bit, it's really good getting someone elses input, when you stare at it for ages you tend to just see what you want to see and don't notice what needs to be done.
8/10 for your sig, I love the simplicity but just not keen on the part on the left, or the pink spots around her head. But it is very styly!
-
Much much better, 8/10.
Hit me up on xfire ( morfien05 ) if you want and CnC and tips and tricks on your sigging.
-
8/10 :)
-
7/10
9/10 love it :)
-
8/10
6.5/10
7/10
-
7/10 Never been a big fan of putting dates and stuff in sigs like that...
8/10 Right side doesn't seem to work with the render for some reason.
-
7/10
610
-
5-6/10 - Very basic.
-
7/10, not a bad sig
-
5/10
7/10 - Very bright..
-
8.5/10
-
7/10
8/10
-
7/10
Sam fisher in samus helmet |
V
-
5/10
-
7/10 its just not my cupa tea It looks Like its been cut out of a magazine and you have whacked some text on it
-
8.5/10
-
looks Like its been cut out of a magazine and you have whacked some text on it
Thanks xD.
7/10
8/10
Removed link, wasn't too family appropriate~LEGO
-
7/10
-
10/10
Perfect
-
-100/10 because Of this
10/10
Perfect
...
6/10 Its good Just a bit Fuzzy
-
2/10
Leo is yet to make me my new star warsy BFM sig. :LOL: :P
if he makes it ill give him a 6/10 :)
You can rate the halo dude with the lightsaber if u want.
Give the pony a low score....leo made it :P
-
6.5/10
7/10
7.5/10
5/10
-
8/10
9.5/10
-
( for the one with the c4d, and sais "racer of the future" ) 7/10, pretty good, but pretty empty..
And I could only give that smashing sig a 1000/10, who made that awsome sig? xD.
-
Lol. For ALL of your sigs, like the ones in the link, i give a healthy 8.5/10 ;D
-
First few, around 7/10
Bottom one, 9.5/10
-
-100/10 because Of this
10/10
Perfect
Don't lie it's awesome lol.
Well I guess I'm rating you, Mith. The top one is 8/10 because I love the render there.
The team sig is 1/10... Team Lucky... Man I hate those guys.
-
7/10
-
7/10- Overall, you had a couple of nice ones in there.
7/10- I'm not a fan of the white border on the top and bottom, nice sig other then that though.
-
7/10 - Reflection is awsome, font is awome, but a bad choice in mask for the clipping mask.
-
7/10 - also not a fan of the white border on the top and bottom, otherwise it looks nice.
-
8/10 i like the design of it and the letters
-
8/10 Bit too reddish for me
Oh BTW be sure to rate the top one too, not just the aov one (:
-
Both 5/10..
-
6/10
7/10
6/10
-
5/10
6/10
10/10
10/10
1/10
-
4.5/10
5.5/10 - Considering your level of skill, very messy, too contrasted, the light is weird and doesnt look right and a fair few other things. Its perfectly fine to have alot of things wrong with people begining with the whole sig buisness, just kui and you will get better.
1/10 - wth, thats horrible xD.
-
For ALL of your sigs (including link) 8.5/10 :)
-
6/10 for the whole sig, got a few good ones in there.
7/10 for the second, still the white bar that I don't like.
-
8.9452348230485/10 ;D
-
9/10
8/10
0/10 - ewww canada
-
10/10 for the creepyness of it
-
7/10
-
Its as awesome as it is creepy
10/10
-
10/10 because its by Jane
6/10; Funny but too big
-
9/10
Love the sig Lucky!
-
7/10
7/10
2/10 :P(6/10)
10/10!!!!!
-
7/10 for the bars
(thread revival!!)
-
10/10, love it
oh thanks on the bars, made em myslef ;D
-
6/10-Sig
8/10-Userbars
Yay Shinedown! :)
-
nice to see another shinedown fan, most people never heard of em, even saw em in concert with breaking benjamin ;D
9/10
10/10 for medal, well deserved(and it has nice shine)
and dont remeber last so 7/10
-
your sig made me lol so 7/10
-
5-6/10 - kinda looks like a stock with text slapped on, I could be wrong, though.
7/10 - Made me lol :P
-
9/10
8/10
8/10
dude, your sigs are actually quite awesome, they just look good :)
-
8/10 nice sig there Inferno!
-
7/10
9/10 for userbar
8/10 (team sig)
-
7/10 8/10 10/10
-
Oh so since it's Edi's it's the worst? :LOL:
9/10 awesome
-
8/10
-
7/10
8/10
-
10/10
8/10(colors just kinda too dark or im stinning to low in the chair :LOL:)
99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999/10
annada rocks, even tho i live one stste away
-
8/10 love that shotty!
-
8/10
5/10
6/10
-
10/10! :)
-
10/10
9.5/10
Meh 5/10
-
10/10
9.5/10
Meh 5/10
anti canadian, eh?
canadas awesome
anyways,
9/10
10/10
userbar 99999999999999999999/10
-
4/10 too abnormal imho
-
4/10 too abnormal imho
lol thnk you lucky :LOL: :P
-
3/10
-
10/10 agen, still amazing
how ya guys like my new sig? ;D
-
7/10 lol niiice :)
-
really looks cool, 9.9/10 the light just go's to fast for my taste
now my newest and favorite sig which got my seal of approval ---> ;D<---
-
6/10
-
6/10
no lego no! :LOL: :LOL: :LOL:
my better one gets rated less? :siderofl: :siderofl: :siderofl:
u mock my awesomneness :P
same scores as before
-
5/10
-
its the bottom left text, aint it? :LOL:
7/10(more boring more i see it)
999999999/10000000
always loved the 2nd one, glad its back
approved ;D
-
5/10
Text Needs Improvement
Background is too liquified.
-
7/10
-
8/10
9/10
6/10
-
8/10 +1 for being purple=9/10
7/10 +1 for being purple=8/10
7/10 +1 for being purple=8/10
;D
-
10/10
9/10
999999999999999999999999/10 Canada FTW!
-
8/10
9/10, i love how the render flows with the background :)
Awesome :)
-
8/10
-
8/10
9/10
7/10
-
8/10 5/10
6/10
-
6/10
8/10 - Love the text
-
9/10
9.5/10
9/10
-
7/10
-
8/10
7/10
6/10
-
7/10
9/10 <- i really love the explosion like effect of it, looks neat :)
6/10
Inferno.
-
6-7/10 - Alright for your level I gues, kiu!
-
7/10
8/10
8/10
-
8/10
-
8/10
7/10
9/10
-
7/10, looks good, just not great, opinion only..
-
7/10
-
8/10, the CoD4 one looked a lot better, chief just doesnt fit it
10/10, all of McSkittles are awesome, Pure genious
6/10, bit basic
-
8/10
-
10/10
8/10
And thanks Trae! ;D
-
7/10 - Like the idea, but the text and the bar thing around the text kill it.
6/10
7/10 - Would be higher but I dispise pop-out sigs :P
-
7/10
8/10
8/10
-
8/10
8/10
6/10
Could someone please rate this one too?
(http://i598.photobucket.com/albums/tt69/Terra_55/goodCod4Sig.png) (got blurred when i uploaded :angry:)
-
7/10, looks cool just very blurred
10/10, had a lot of good ones in there, and i like animations
10, thats an awesome team sig
-
6/10 <- looks like a c4d pasted on top of a radiant background, just doesnt look right
8/10 <- blending and colours used well, i liked it.
-
6/10 <-- Methinks tis too simple
8/10 <-- very busy and the guy seems to blend into the background :)
-
6/10 6/10 7/10
9/10
-
8/10 for both
-
7/10
9/10
6/10
3/10 ascii
-
(http://i892.photobucket.com/albums/ac126/bfmgeek2/Signatures/HOUSEMD-1.png)
Please Rate!! :D
-
9/10
The render should blend in a little more with the background imo
-
8/10
-
8/10
10000000000000000000000000000000000/10 for the other two as they are epic. :XD: :LOL:
-
Oh Skittles..
9/10, still remember it, twas beautiful then and still is.
7/10
8/10 for good use of colour :D
-
8/10 8/10
-
That's really good Geek, I'd say 8.5/10
You've got a good feel for colours and techniques, the simplistic feel really complements the render. My only criticisms are the scissors on the right seem a bit out of place, and almost give it a bit of a kiddy feel. And the render could be colour balanced to blue a wee bit more so that it fits into the sig better.
-
strangly todaym your sig seems odd :eyebrow:
7/10
-
strangly todaym your sig seems odd :eyebrow:
7/10
Yea, I'm not really a big fan of my current sig anymore.. I'll have to make a new one when I get back to my computer in a few weeks.
6/10
6/10
-
7/10
-
7/10
8/10
7/10
6/10
-
7/10 I likes the space and the pixalation. ^^ Though if you could have converted the house persons picture into a 98 looking recording for ingame cut scene i'd have given it higher. ^^
Score userbar too please. ^^;
-
Userbar is a 6/10. It's a little large, the colours contrast quite sharply and it just doesn't seem as slick as it should be... That said, it's a great effort.
The sig is a 6/10 too.
-
8/10 the avatar thing is awesome but the background is kinda dodgy, i dont know why
-
8/10
6/10
7/10
-
9/10
10/10
7/10
-
8/10 6/10
6/10 6/10
-
7/10
6/10
This is slightly experimental but:
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/Swell.png)
-
that one hmm creppy but cool, 8/10
the car, 6/10, too simple
te sniper, 10/10 its even kind of an animation
slash slash slash, 10/10 for sig, 99999999999999999999999/10 for slash
-
8/10
6/10
-
5/10
7/10 - for the userbars
6/10
-
8/10
7/10
7/10
6/10
-
Top image 9/10
Bottom image 10/10
-
5.5/10
6/10
Rate Lucky/Edison trophy please.
-
8/10 i like shiny gold things :drool:
-
5/10
6/10
-
4/10
4/10
-
All of them look too monochromatic imho; and still not a fan of those white lines
5/10
5/10
6/10
4/10
-
8/10
-
7
8
4
-
5/10
-
6/10
-
8/10
9/10 =D
-
4/10 - wth is that thing? And border kills it...
-
Its a Penguin!! Arya I would give it a 7 ;)
Velocity, yours would be:
7/10
6/10
7/10
7/10
-
thanks lego ;D lol =P
i think i already rated yours but forgot the user bar xD
9/10 yay canadians :P
-
8/10 because it is sooooo true :)
-
7/10
7/10
8/10 7/10
also rate what u think of what i say in my sig
-
6/10
6/10
7/10
6/10
-
Isnt it just custom that your sigs are 10/10 :P. I like that one allot :)
Can some one please rate this one for me :)
(http://i26.tinypic.com/t9dwrr.jpg)
-
6/10 - Border and text kill it for me..
-
7/10
9/10
10/10
7/10
-
10/10
8/10
Start the ratings with the halo one
-
On average - 4/10
1/10 - ...
-
8/10
6/10
6/10
5/10
-
9/10
7/10
8/10
8/10
-
(not rating userbars)
8/10
7/10 (too tall and thin)
-
I'll just rate your sig, not your trophies (but trophies would be 10/10, nice job)
10/10 for the sig.
Can some1 rate this please?
(http://i29.tinypic.com/2zq6kj8.jpg)
-
It's probably an 8/10 considering the fact that you made it from a picture (because he told you to lol) which is kinda harder and never could look as good as one from scratch.
Edit: rate these along with my sig please! :o
(http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/4286/pointblankluckysig.png)
(http://img716.imageshack.us/img716/1184/animatedsig.gif)
-
(Starting with the 1st one posted)
6/10
7/10
7/10
Im not a big fan of the pop-out sigs, but these are alright I gues.
-
6/10
8.5/10
10/10
5/10
-
9/10
7/10
11/10 (cow sig = lols)
10/10
-
8/10 - I love vector sigs, but this looks too sharp in some areas, mainly around the focal/ render.
-
Soild 8/10, I really like em, But i think thed look a little better if you re - aranged them a little bit, like have it
SIG SIG
SIG SIG
instead of
SIG
SIG
SIG
SIG
2c
-
9/10 for the car sig.
10/10 for the zombie bit at the bottom, I love it!!!
-
Loved the animated cow one 10/10 :D
-
6/10 5/10
5/10 5/10
All are lq and/ or too sharp
-
8/10
8/10
8/10
7/10
-
9/10
8/10
-
9/10, that looks pretty epic :) cool text.
-
The render kind of fraks me out xD
6/10.. sorry.
-
6/10
9/10
8/10
Pretty good sigs =)
-
Love the sig :) 10/10
-
3/10
2/10
10/10
-
7/10
4/10
10/10 cowwws :D
7/10
nice :)
-
7/10
every single anime sig looks like this but it is still pretty cool so the only points lost were for unoriginality :P
-
8/10 - Super original and Looks Randomly good :D
trophies are around 7/10.
v - Only Temporary until i can make a decent sig - v (from around 2 years ago)
-
5/10 cus it seems really grainy and as if it has lots of compression/was zoomed in on and has low resolution.
Rate Aussie 3 v 3 sig and Lucky Edison trophy please.
-
Lucky/Edison: 3/10
3v3: 9/10 :)
-
6/10
8/10
9/10 - really like the last one, the colours work well.
-
6/10 - Very very messy
-
6/10
8/10
7/10
7/10
not too bad, a little simple perhaps but they look alright.
-
Hmm... 7/10
-
6/10
10/10
8/10
-
6/10
8/10
-
8/10
7/10
-
5/10... It's okay, the render seems like it was stretched out of its original dimensions.
-
7/10
In my opinion pop out sigs are incredibly overused, most of the time they look like you made an average design in a box and placed a render on top of it. If you had rotated it clock-wise just a little and made the sword the only thing that popped out it would be a bit better. If you were going with the idea I just said too, then you could also make the blur more noticeable around the sword and toned it down around the rest of the render. The originality of writing your name and the symbols on the sword is what made this a 7/10.
Trophies:
5/10 9/10 7/10 8/10
-
I agree with Jay, well kinda lol.. I wouldn't say there over used, but I've thats the only style ive seen from lucky, which is a pretty bad thing.
1. They look very basic (unless pulled off with some great effects)
and 2. You gotta expand your styles/ technique, u'll never learn anything doing the same crud over and over again.
Just saying...
And the sig, 6-7/10 - Too many stars and they stickout too much, and the pen tooling is a lil thick.
-
5/10... It's okay, the render seems like it was stretched out of its original dimensions.
not stretched the render was just like that.
7/10 all together, just seem a little basic.
-
9 for the singer, i like it
7 for the cod one, its nice
the link sig is my first sig ive made, tell me what you think :)
-
8/10 Farrariiiiiii :XD: 7/10 It is great for a first time, but the gradients are a bit wacky
-
6/10
5/10 - Depth fail, the background is waaaaaay to sharp
-
9/10
10/10
10/10
8/10 very good overall
-
Overall: 6/10
-
10/10 for the one Velocity made for you!
-
10/10. Willing to go 11/10 if possible.
-
6/10 got old
7/10, good but poorly rendered.
Didnt load?
v new v A:
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/angelussig.png)
yes it does have a border, but it's black.
-
8/10 Colours match (And its a good show ;D)
-
7/10
3-4/10
-
9
9
8
9
GReat sigs!
-
9/10. Really good but don't like how the M looks (how the black bit cuts it off from its leg).
Rate the timberland sig please (and yes, I know the is a black line which shouldn't be there. accident. don't rate it based on that please).
-
7/10
I like the view its from
-
9/10, like tanxs said. I like it. A lot. But no one ever gets a full 10/10 in anything! :P
-
7/10 <- better as an avatar
7/10 <- well Animated not great quality
8/10 <- Well animated, good quality
-
4/10 - Not a bad effort, I like the colour, but the effects don't really tie together and I'm not keen on the text.
9/10 - Very nice! Really love the colours and effects, and the lighting is spot on. :) Yay WoW! ;D
Please rate this one:
(http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg81/BFM_Hlao/Signatures/FlyleafSignature-2.png)
-
I wont lie to you hlao, I dont know who these people are :P
I think making real people in a sig is hard to pull off, but i think you did a good job. 7/10
-
8/10 really cool!
-
8/10
Like what you did with the Text
-
7
9
cause link is awesome ;D
-
8/10
9/10
8/10
Some good sigs in there mate.
-
8/10 - too green
4/10 - imho a bad attempt at going out of the frame. Too bland as well
-
9/10, quite clever new scrim season i guess? simple animation with a large ammount of time put into it, i like it :)
rate:
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/Bond.png)
and ofcourse my current sig :)
-
sig you made in post 9/10
your current sig freaks me out somehow. 10/10. awsome render but the render freaks me out somehow. :(
-
1/10 annoying and disorienting, so much so that I used adblock to block it
-
6/10.. Dont like it that much, bit blank..
8/10. Someone put alot of effort into it, and its awesome execpt it takes forever and ever to load on slow internet.
-
7/10, it's alright, well made with a simple vibe, looks ok :)
6/10, never a fan of popout sigs, but it looks ok if a little bit bland.
-
9/10
10/10
1/10 annoying and disorienting, so much so that I used adblock to block it
Let's see if my new one can get blocked from Lucky as well! :muah:
-
^^5/10^^
its not too bad but it should only be used in the avatar! :zoid:
if any one wants the type of creatures/alienz ive got down the bottem of mah sig, look at geting an acount on this: http://www.heresy-online.net/daemons/index.php
(anyone mind clicking on those stupid things as well? thx if u do! :hug:)
-
6/10 It is a bit blurry.
-
first one is 4/10, getting really old
the horsmen are pretty cool, 8/10
-
8/10 <- you do spend alot of time on your sigs dont you lucky? well i liked this 1 but i personally dont think the mosiac squares work with the render, otherwise it's pretty decent.
9/10 <- simply because it's clever and well thought out.
-
Actually I ussually don't take a tremendous amount of time on them ;)
You first one I love, 9/10, the text is a little bland (same with the background) but the render is cool which is the main reason it is so high. (Looks even better in the avatar)
Second one I don't like as much. The render isn't as good so I guess i'll give it a 6/10
-
8/10 i prefered the one with just Lucky
7/10 it's a bit too dark
-
First one is 8/10. It looks pretty good except the text is very bland. I personally don't like the vertical text but more than that it has no effects and is a very basic font. If the text had more time put into it then it would be higher, everything else is good tho.
second one; 5/10. It is too big first off. Not only that, but the render's copy slightly to the side isn't opasitized or blurred enough. I can see what you were trying to do but it just looks like I'm seeing double. It's also very bland and monochromatic.
-
8/10 for both, there nice
rate my new (and old ones) please
(http://i55.tinypic.com/95ygxj.png)
tried something different and i think it looks cool
-
8/10 7/10 6/10 Not bad sigs there mate
Had a go making a very simplistic quick sig, pls rate + current sigs
(http://i598.photobucket.com/albums/tt69/Terra_55/BoeingF-18Sig.png)(F/A-18 Hornet FTW :P)
-
Hornet: 8/10 (cos of the popout)
Redish one: 9.9/10
SOTM: 7/10
-
not bad panther
say 8/10
mine is prop not that good and trying to improve
-
2/10 simply cause its just a pic (although its a pretty sweet car! :smly_a_wink: )
-
7/10
-
iv already rated urs panther
what my new one like
-
3/10
It looks much more like a signature with the render and all. Its a bit to big though. The render isnt cut out to well. Border needed and mabey mess with the text a bit.
But hey, youve already improved a bunch and youre still learning! Its a good first sig and if you keep practicing youll only get better and thats the fun part of it! If you go on youtube and look up gimp tricks or gimp know how, you can learn a bunch! Keep up the good work! :yesyes:
-
video tutorials -.- gosh i hate them
anyways, 7/10, good effect but a litle bit blurry... and 7/10, for the same reason, it's all very blurry.
Try out some written tutorials mate, they include alot more detail and are easier to follow 98% of the time.
-
8/10- i like it!
recently got photoshop and have been trying out a few tutorials and things, pl0x rate them too :)
-
8/10
6/10 9/10
7/10
a nice selection of sigs mate :)
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/Bikesig.png)
-
8/10 ( i like the bike)
(http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w251/dekollen/neo-2-ballen-klein.gif)
-
10/10 it's awesome!
-
bout 6-7/10
how my new one
-
- /10
What sig?
-
battlecruiser text is 9/10 for me
-
6/10 Theres tomuch Going on in the backround 5/10 ITS NOT A MUD KIP
6/10
-
7/10
5/10
7/10
-
8/10, 8/10, 7.5/10
-
8/10 <- simple with a good effect, would look good with a visible border. 7/10
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/Hawksig.png)
That Inferno.
-
One in post 6/10. Not much color and looks too blurry, white isn't very pleasing to look at if there's that much of it. Also the render is...different.
One in sig 7/10, little bit more color or variety would have been nice, but other said things don't apply to this one. Also the render doesn't quite fit in with the background.
-
7/10 like the font you used
(http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w251/dekollen/oranje500x250.jpg)
-
7
Neat idea, but it's hard to read some of the text. I liked the background mainly.
-
8/10 - I liked it
11/10 - ROFL!
-
10/10 i like them
-
Thanks.
10/10
6/10
8/10
-
5/10, even though I made it, it's not one of my best efforts.
10/10 because JANE is so awesome
5/10, it is too big, and I didn't like that render, the border is only on the top and bottom which looks bad imo
-
:)
-
:)
You're supposed to rate the previous person's sig.
-
8/10 :)
-
first 6
second 5
-
7/10 for the aussie thing
4/10 For the rest
-
Too basiccccccccc - 3/10
0/10 - LEO, I don't think that quote reflects your life at all
-
2/10 Looks like yove just taken a picture Off Google
-
1/10 leo a little plain no offense
-
6/10 (pixels look a little compressed, like a HUGE pic got squeezed into a small sig format)
9/10 (definitely the best of the three)
7/10
-
7/10
-
All three are too boxy for my taste but putting that aside...
9/10 I like the swirl you did, looks good.
8/10 - nice fire effect
7/10
-
ummmmm its perrty 9.5/10
-
9/10
9/10
8/10
-
Don't mind me, or rate my sig, cuz it's just a userbar. Rate Benjy's..
But...
All three are too boxy for my taste but putting that aside...
They're too boxy for your taste.
Boxy.
Boxxy.
:love:
-
99/10 @ Zakk's
-
didn't you make that userbar WeeGee?
10/10 either way.
Instead of rating mine tell me which one you like better and why please
-
I like the blue one because you can see the detail better.
-
I kind of merged both of them for best result :P
10/10 for your LBP one, JANE. I really like it because it goes with the LBP 2d style. I can't really explain it very well but it looks really good for the theme it was done on. The text also goes great with the sig. I hope you saved the editable because you should put your name under the LittleBigPlanet and make it ur perm sig! :D
-
soild 10 lucky its nice
rate this ont as well plz
(http://i51.tinypic.com/288cpw1.png)
Ive never heard of little big planet before so I am convinced this thing is evil
-
9/10 - Pretty pro..
8/10
9/10 - Because pokemon is awesome..
9/10
-
9/10
7/10
-
8/10 Like the effect
-
(Sorry last time I'll spam here for awhile!)
7/10 for the TERRA text. I like your idea, however it looks slightly too low quality to look glossy enough to be how I think you meant it to be. Like in Jay's sig, it reflects from the bottom and glows slightly to give it more of a glossy look, if you are going to do the picture in the text like that, that's what I'd suggest. Still pretty good tho
9/10 I think this one would have been better if you did some color/contrast adjustments to it. Just my opinion, I think that it puts a nice seal on it if you do that. Also I think the render would have looked better maybe smudged some in the background and possibly less going on. Best out of the three, however, with all that said.
7/10 - When originally making this I meant for it to look more glossy and sharp, but it didn't turn out that way. So I might have a warped opinion of this one, but idk I guess it still looks pretty good. I think I could have gotten the depth alot better if I had tried harder. However I do like the fact that it's not in a border whatsoever. If you guys win I might consider taking some of that and putting a gold tint on it and taking out some of the text and replacing it with "Champions" or something. seems like that would make a good trophy.
Rate this as well as my sig pl0x.
(http://img151.imageshack.us/img151/6729/yoshilucky.png)
-
A billion out of 10
because yoshi is awesome and so is that sig
-
9/10 for the DBZ sig, my only problem is the text might be a bit hard to see.
8/10 not sure what that thing is, but again with the text.
7/10
-
8/10 - Awesome, but no text? :-X
7/10? - Not sure how to rate an RS sig.. :-\ but nice stats anyways
-
8/10 - Awesome, but no text? :-X
7/10? - Not sure how to rate an RS sig.. :-\ but nice stats anyways
Lol take a look at my compiled sigs thread, not alot of them have text because the ones that do look like crap because of it. :P
Anyway, 9/10
8/10
-
7/10 Okay but a bit too simplistic
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/zakpak.png)
ONLY rate this one. Pls dont rate the other ones
-
5/10 - The main problems with this one are as follows: 1.) There is no sense of depth in the signature, I can't tell where the render ends and the background begins, and 2.) The signature is far too messy. It also looks too gritty at some parts. The main thing though is that the background does not go well with the render. It blends too much and I can't tell what's what when looking at it. There seems to be too much going on and then you look at the text and there's almost nothing. I've seen this with alot of people recently but it looks as if whoever created the sig was driven to make it as complex as possible then ran out of steam when it came to the text and put no effort into it at all. It (I know I have used this reference alot lately) literally looks as if someone forgot to put text on the sig and went back and just added it on Paint. The font also does not go well with the rest of the sig in my opinion.
-
y'know, i'm just gunna post here and wait for lucky's witty remarks, because he seems to only pick on the work that i do nowadays :bang:
but to keep on topic,
6/10, just 3 sets of text with a backdrop inside an outline.
-
7/10
Btw the point of the text standing alone is to be simple. So rating it lower because it is simple kind of defeats the purpose.
[/witty remarks]
-
8/10 since it seems like the contrast caused one side of the reflection to be seen too well compared to the other.
-
The sig in my sig....erm yeah is the first one ive made in a really long time, would justl ike an opinion on it, im a bit rusty.
Edit: Edisons sig i rate 7.5/10 A bit too plain for meh.
-
thats cool weegee but i rate it a 8/10
-
10/10 because i made it :)
track king's wont load for me, so idk
-
9/10, i like this one, alot, mainly because it looks pretty epic in it's own way, the flow works well and so do the colours.
Sorta Monotonic, and the border is weird but still rate awayy:
(http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/dd82/343-Fury-343/mustangsig.png)
as well as my sig sig please :D
-
9/10 for the top one.
7/10 for the bottom. (looks a little plain to me)
-
5/10
-
9/10
-
10/10 :)
-
10/10, Lucky always does good stuff :)
-
9/10, really like that piece, good colours that work well together with the render, the flow is correct and it's sort of soothing... so overall good :)
-
8/10
-
Bigman you always have the best sigs. I really liked your old ones with a blue blury spartan and vegetio
anyways
9
10
10
I really like em :)
-
10/10
(top right) 8/10
7/10
-
I don't see too much wrong with It, though there Is something a little fishy I just can't put my tongue on It.
9/10 Good job man
-
7/10
5/10
They're just userbars, but I do prefer the top one over the bottom.
-
What are you trying to say? xD
splash of colors 7/10
complex 8/10
-
6/10, it looks ok, just the white doesnt go well without a border on the black background :(
userbars: 7/10
-
8/10
9/10
-
8/10
9/10 <cuz of the beast stats
-
5/10
It's really random lol
-
8/10
4/10
:)
-
9/10
7/10 - like the effect but its just a little plain
Once again - im trying a new style and different effects
(http://i598.photobucket.com/albums/tt69/Terra_55/crashsig.png)
(i am no good when it comes to text :bang:)
-
7/10 for the crash :)
-
8/10 for the nice arm in the water :) :winkgrin:
-
7/10 <- the memories!
8/10 <- cool looking from neo as always
6/10 <- not the greatest :( but it looks ok.
-
9/10... does mc-pro count as a word? :P
-
8/10 i love the green wavy effect
6/10 cool sig but im not much of a field hockey fan
-
6/10
6/10
-
5.6/10
(http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w251/dekollen/hide_eyes_.png)
-
Creativity I say!!!!
Very Interesting
9/10
8/10
-
8/10, i still like it
5/10 <-the image wont load for some reason, so i'm gunna give it a 5 for matching the forums :)
v took a bit of time, but was fun to create
-
8/10(It made me giggle)
-
6/10
(Don't rate AUSSIE, work in progress)
-
6/10
10/10 (GO TEAM!)
8/10
Don't rate the Blarg I shoot you with mah lazor thing, the aussie or the USA plz :)
-
10/10 once again, Lucky's Awesomesauce
9/10
-
9/10, looks pretty amazing, just needs a tad more colour maybe?
7/10 runescape sig, but it's got good stats.
1 old and 1 new from me.:
-
Left: 6/10 Kinda weird.
Right 5/10
-
Lucky's 10/10
JANE's 8/10
MrT's 8/10
Aussie... >9000
-
Purple theme ;D
Top: 6/10
Middle: 6/10
Bottom: lol RS uhhh I don't know anything about It so....10/10 ;D
-
6/10. it be better with out that bit to the left
6/10
-
7/10
8.5/10
10/10 :DDD
-
Scrim sig - 10.....0000000/10
Rate all Pl0x
-
+The userbar Is very clear, who ever designed It did an excellent job 9/10
+I love abstract art, this one Is a bunch of colors spilled over a canvas, to say and the text matches quite well, which Is usually for a lot of people something hard to master 9/10
+The scrim sig Is pretty cool looking, has that whole futuristic look to It, and Isn't just a rectangle, has an abnormal shape, though some of the white text and parts of Mastercheif look a bit too bright 7/10
+Mr T's created sig, not really sure how to grade this one. I don't particularly like this one, just doesn't appeal to me 5/10
+Everyone has these now, new trend to say. I think there should be another layer at the top and bottom so that the word spaces don't mix In with the outlining. 7/10
Just my 2 cents about everything. ;D
-
nice mc hammer one 7/10
the second gets 8
and the third isnt coming up
what is my new one like
-
2.5/10 where you write your name on wall. It's neat how you did your name, but it doesn't look that good. And there is white edges.
5/10 for the sig I made. I know I made it, but I don't like it that much :P. The render u supplied me with looked good tho.
-
8/10
-
Anime guru 7/10
-
"you wanted me now here i am" sig 7.5/10
I've been told this is my best sig ever, so let's see what ya'll think!
-
It's ok. Text ruins it. Looks like you went on an external site to put the unoriginal animated text on it. But whatever 6/10 i guess
-
Love the scrim sig 9/10
6/10 for other
-
MC Hammer Sig: 7/10, hm mm! Old school is whats up.
-
I just gotta pop in here really quick and say I Love Your Sig Tek! G.J.! ummmm 9/10
(No such thing as perfect but yours is close to it! :-X )
Moving on now, i have no sig so next person just continue with Teks'....
:)
-
ASCII text... cool.
>9000/10
-
8/10
Runescape stuff doesn't count as sigs.
-
yoshi
the sig is good too
8/10
and i like the team sig as well
7/10
-
6/10
It's good being as you're just beginning! d_b
I would love to see what some1 thinks of my sig :)
-
9.9/10 idk if i like the rain bow colors, but the animation is smooth and clean.
-
10/10 for the avatar
(What? This isn't the avatar game? SORRY BUT I HAD TO GIVE IT A RATING IT'S AWESOME)
9/10 for your sig! It looks awesome!
And MiG, what animation? I wanted you to rate JANE saying I'm a freak (JK!).
-
Pandas <3
9/10
Yes, you are a freak <3. 10/10
-
9/10
7/10
Dude? :P /10
Like the first one though.. :)
-
9/10
7/10
-
4/10 looks like you just got a picture off google.
-
9/10
*I love your's Trael!
-
A bit big. 7/10
-
9/10 for sig
100000/100000 for runescape chatbox ;D
-
Pandas -10/10 - Why you may ask? Pandas are awesome and Tanxs1 is awesome. That sig has both...
Hydra vs Tanxs1 -100000/10 -ROFL
-
Top to bottom;
8/10
7/10
5/10
-
5/10 - The discoloration and over-saturation of the render ruins the quality of the sig imo. It also has no text or name which should be included in the sig, otherwise it's just a picture :P.
Also, the background looks like you just rendered some clouds on Photoshop and "called it a day". However, at least you didn't try to get fancy and horizontally flip the render and go around thinking you're the next big thing. ;D
So, all in all, it looks bland, but at least it's a little pleasing to look at. It doesn't look flat out unpleasing to the eye.
-
:eyebrow: The over saturation was intended, as the character is in a war zone and he is looking at an explosion. I could have attempted to put something else in the background, but it was late and I just wanted to enter it :happy:
I didn't put text on it because I know I would have ruined it :P
I'd give yours 7.5/10, it's a little too busy for my liking, but it's pretty cool.
-
6/10, the colors work well, but as lucky says, it's a little bland with the clouds... +it'd be nice to have a border.
-
9/10 - Very nice sig
-
You already know my thoughts, but
10/10
8/10
-
7/10, it seems a bit...bland...
9/10, I like it.
-
8/10. its textures blend with the text :D
-
7/10 <-organised
8/10 <- well made
8/10 <- i made it, but i could've done better with the text, let me know if ya want me to play about to improve it.
A-Samson
-
7/10, a bit too hazy for me
(http://i53.tinypic.com/1564yrp.jpg)
And this one is ancient, made by a member of the JR clan back in 06 that I dug up (the signature, not the member) ;D
(http://i53.tinypic.com/2safcs1.jpg)
-
9/10
-
Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. I love it.
10/10
-
I think I've already commented on yours before Mderms but I'll say a 8/10!
I Like!
:)
-
I really like it :)
9.5/10 :D
-
8 / 10 i like it me
the text is a 7 out of 10 simple but it works
-
8/10
10/10 for the text :LOL: made me chuckle.
-
<3
9001
-
7/10
(http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w251/dekollen/sotmmay2011.png)
-
8/10
The -db-NEO looks great, however, the Kill be or whatever it then says is obviously very difficult to read for someone with eyes as old as mine. Great render and background though :D
-
8-10 its very nice and well made just a bit busy for my taste
-
Love It 8/10
-
5/10
Kinda blurry.
-
9/10 - very nice
7/10 - very clean animation/transition but the only good panda is a sad panda :P
-
MiG, you have the coolest color combinations!
All-together 9/10
-
7/10 cuz i like lord of the rings but its perty simple
-
3/10
6.5/10
I know they were both made by me :P
-
I'll give it an 8 theb
-
9-10, looks like a good render and I like the simplicity of the sig overall. Only complaint is that it looks a tad blurry which is probably on purpose but the same pattern covers a majority of the sig and makes it look a little redundant. However the grungy look goes great with the render.
(Please don't rate them all. Just choose one and actually critique it please)
-
Well I can't really criticize any seeing as they are so awesome. I especially love the guitar one :D 10/10 for that :)
-
8/10 I love the style =)
10/10 Minecraft is awesome <3
-
8/10
Are pandas awesome, Xsix? :)
-
Pandas are quite awesome.
10/10
-
Love it except for that blue splodge.
7/10 (Woulda been a nine without the splodge :))
-
8/10, a good clean sig, well structured.
7/10, a good animation, colourful but simple
Both look good to me
-
7/10 I like the style =)
-
Very clear and well made! 9/10 for both.
-
7/10
-
Love it except for that blue splodge.
7/10 (Woulda been a nine without the splodge :))
NOOOOOO i give it 9/10 i love the blue splodgy thing and the rest of the sig is very clear good job!
-
i love the blue splodgy thing
+1
6/10 - The sig itself is very basic and there's not much to look at, but I love the text which is pretty much why it's a 6/10
4/10 - Too much going on, no sense of depth; messy
-
Well, like I said, 10/10 for all except for the orangy one. 9/10 for that.
-
I really like JANE's vault boy sig, that particular pose is actually my Steam avatar but anyway it's a 10/10
For the Minecraft one it has a pretty simple animation but nice colors so 8/10 because the animation seems unrealistic and imo would look better slower and without the stops. That would make it look more abstract which would go better with the font imo.
-
10/10
is that Hunk? I see an umbrella badge
-
Yes, it's for the Resident Evil theme :P
10/10 love the animation
-
9/10
-
9/10 10/10 8/10
7/10
ASCII American flag 9/10
-
7/10
8/10
9/10
-
8/10
9/10
6/10
-
9/10
-
L°§tMyMiNÐ speaking...
And I give your sig 9 Stars out of 10, LeCrae, I mean, §tair§.
- L°§tMyMiNÐ
-
I really like the simplicity :D
9/10
-
9/10
10/10
6/10
-
8.5
-
Looks really awesome! 10/10
-
8/10 for the signature and 7/10 for the rainbow text. (Sorry Tanxs1 :[ - It's just a bit distracting)
-
9/10
-
9/10
its nice
-
9/10
And whoever gets to rate Lucky's sig next time, he automatically get a >9000/10, LOL!!!
-
love pink floyd and loved every sig you make mderms :) 10/10 and just cuz 10/10 for ur avatar very interesting
-
The font Is really good 9/10
-
7.5/10
Main issue is with the text, whose possible changes I mentioned in the thread of its creation.
-
11/10
It's majestic and inspiring. And I like the colors.
-
Nicely fine there, 8.5/10
-
8.5/10
The dust/rust could use a little more depth to it I think.
-
8/10 ... it's too pretty. :-X
:LOL:
-
3rd one: 9/10
-
6/10, fairly standard :P
9/10, i like it, it's busy and themed well :)
-
6/10 My taste for a car of that sort would require a bit more going on, and possibly a darkness around It Instead of light
-
8/10. I like the darkness around it
-
7/10
6/10
-
all are very nice i think it will be
8/10
9/10
6/10
-
10/10, not just because it has DJ PON-3, the colours work well with the colour scheme of the forums.
11/10 because I'm Rainbow Dash!
-
erm.. what do you have to do? :P
-
erm.. what do you have to do? :P
Rate the sigs of the most recent poster. Like so:
4/10 ---- 4/10 ---- 8/10
the 4/10's just look like internet pics with text on top, but the Season V sig looks really nice.
-
8/10
8/10
-Not Including Userbars
-
7/10
8/10
-
8/10 (Only because there's no border)
7/10 (It's a good sig, but not colourful enough for me ;))
-
0/10
4/10
-
7/10
8/10
-
9/10
10/10 for the award, because you wouldn't have it if you weren't awesome :P
Geez it's been a while since I've been on this thread
-
9/10 for iRobot
-
5/10, looks like it didn't take much effort to make
-
Get this thread going again!
8/10 bottom one
-
9/10 I've always loved that WALL-E sig
6/10
-
9/10, That gengar one is nice
5/10, sorry not a fan of that one
-
8/10, good but old >.>
-
10/10, a great sig as always. I really like the background, something I can never get to work right. :P
-
I like your backgrounds! <3
8/10 A bit too bright for my taste. But then again I like dark sigs. Text is also a little hard to read but other than that good piece of work.
9/10 I really like this one, the design of the sig is excellent when it comes to positioning of render and text (I love that font too). The glowy line also adds a nice touch. Simple but not too simple.
-
9/10, since when did you get really good at making them? :P
-
9/10 --- great sig
7/10 --- a little bland for my taste
-
Love it!
9/10
-
8/10
8/10
-
8/10
6/10
-
10/10 --- Great sig Lucky!
5/10 --- The render seems very artificially placed on the background. Also, the background lacks complexity, and the color scheme isn't my favorite.
-
9/10
-
8/10
6/10
-
6/10 for quality, little too blurry.
11/10 for subject matter.
-
8/10
7/10 (cool animation!)
-
10/10 - Really nice sig.
--/10 - not giving a rating since it's a SoTM entry. ;)
:clint: Same goes for my second signature. Please dont give it a rating.
-
I really like that one -- 9/10. It could use a bit more blending/darkening or a contrast boost imo, but the text is very well done so good job there.
--/10 - not giving a rating since it's a SoTM entry. ;)
Edit: To stay with tradition, I guess don't rate my SOTM.
Edit edit: Rate this instead
(http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/6930/lbucksig.png)
-
10/10 ofcourse
-
7 - 10
8.5 - 10
-
10/10
8/10
-
6/10
A border probably would have pushed it up to a 7 or 8 :P
-
8/10
4/10
6/10
-
6/10
7/10
-
5/10
6/10
5/10 (I really could have done better.)
-
7/10
5/10 its ti busy
-
8/10 It's a bit small :P
9/10 Boredom's name is a bit hard to see
-
I made it so i wont rate the top one
4/10 Its has to much unused space
8/10 its good Just a little busy
And i wont rate the team sig
(http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/4679/jackhp.png)
-
7/10 - its good and I know it has a black border but it just gets to me. surely a white border wouldn't have been that bad. borders are important to me
8/10 not bad
1/10, Its just a picture with some text on it.
-
I hate Posting after someone just posted on me but 9/10 its nicely animated the only Sticking point is the text but i guess it fits and the link one is complete rubbish Who ever made it needs to be shot
(http://img832.imageshack.us/img832/9656/lyrabonbon.png)
-
7/10
8/10
-
A solid 9/10, looks good.
-
7/10
-
8/10
7/10
-
9/10
Rate these?
(http://i828.photobucket.com/albums/zz209/katrafied/SasukeRedone.png)
(http://i828.photobucket.com/albums/zz209/katrafied/Vector.png)
-
6/10
9/10
-
7/10
9/10
MLP!
-
6/10 im not a fan but its allright